Sourdough Stottie Cakes

As you may know already I’m dabbling with sourdough, I try to keep baking to the weekend taking Hercules ( my sourdough starter) out of the fridge on Thursday for dough making on Friday (after a couple of feeds) then baking on Saturday morning. I make more dough on Saturday for baking on Sunday. Hercules is fed then returned to the fridge.

The chewy texture of sourdough reminds me of a traditional stottie cake from Northumberland. I couldn’t find anything online for making a sourdough stottie so I set about to make my own. My Gran baked them regularly so I know how a traditional stottie should be and how a shop bought one differs. I’m going to try to make my Gran’s version.

Where does the name come from you ask? To stot something is to bounce if off something, like “stotting a baall off the nettie waal”, or “it’s stotting doon ooutside”, meaning  bouncing a ball of the toilet wall ( in the days of outside loos) or in the latter, it’s raining heavily.

Here’s my recipe, I thought I would have to make a few to get it right but actually the first attempt was pretty close to what I wanted.

Sourdough Stottie Cake.

2 1/4 cups strong white flour

2 tablespoons melted butter

1/4 cup active sourdough discard

1 teaspoon salt

1/2 teaspoon sugar

150 ml warm water

1 tablespoon dried milk powder


Mix the dry ingredients except milk powder in a bowl.

Mix the  milk powder and water, stir in the discard and the oil.

Pour into the flour mixture and bring together into a rough ball. Let it rest 10 minutes.

Stottie cake and pease pudding

Tip onto a floured surface and knead until smooth. Leave to rest covered with a damp tea towel for  minutes.

Flatten out with your hand and put on a baking tray, poke a hole in the centre, and prick with a fork ( I forgot to do this). Leave in the fridge overnight.
Stottie cake and pease pudding

In the morning bring out of the fridge while the oven heats to 200C. Put a tray of water in the bottom of the oven. Pop the stottie in the oven and bake for 15 minutes, turn over and bake another 15 minutes.

It should be cooked, I like to check the internal temperature is about 98 C so I know it’s done. Wrap in a tea towel and leave to cool.

Stottie cake and pease pudding
I made some quick pease pudding to eat with my stottie cake. I soaked yellow split peas overnight then rinsed and put in a pan with water and a stock cube, boil until the peas mush. Keep an eye on the water level and top up if needed. I like a bit of texture so didn’t go completely mush, but I blitzed with a hand blender. As the pease pudding cools it thickens up and becomes spreadable.
Stottie cake and pease pudding
Traditionally the peas would be tied in a clout (cloth) and put in a pan of vegetables, water and bacon bones or ham hock to make pea soup , the peas thicken the soup and the peas in the cloth take on flavour from the stock.
Stottie cake and pease pudding
For a miner’s family this would be 2 cheap filling meals for very little money especially if they grew their own vegetables, pea soup and dumplings and ham and pease pudding sandwiches. My quick version is still very tasty, you can add other things like bacon pieces or onions but we had it plain.

The texture when I cut into the stottie looked right, just a little dense but not too heavy.
Stottie cake and pease pudding

It tasted great, just as I remember it.
Stottie cake and pease pudding

The next day I made another stottie cake but cooked it differently to see if I could get a crust like a shop bought stottie. It was cooked in a cast iron pan then put in the oven to finish off. While it was in the pan I realised why they have a belly button, it lets the steam out and stops it puffing up like a pitta bread.
Stottie cakeIt came out more stodgy, but the crust seemed to have the right texture.
Stottie cakeIt tasted good but I do prefer my Gran’s stottie cake.
Stottie cakeStotties will be a regular feature of my sourdough baking in future, I wonder how my Gran would rate them 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.